Home

Advertisement

Previous Entry | Next Entry

second terms

  • May. 1st, 2009 at 8:02 PM
coffee
Because I'm working on the second Cotterford book, I spent some time earlier this week reading a couple of second books in school story series. I chose two of the more recent series, Anne Digby's Second Term at Trebizon (1979) and Harriet Martyn's Jenny and the New Headmistress (1984).  I also started reading DFB's Captain at Springdale (1932), not because it's a second book, but because it's the only Springdale I have and I'd never read it. So I thought it would be useful to read in terms of going cold into a series I'd never read before.  Except I found I did know a few of the characters, courtesy of Dimsie (who also appears in this book).

Second Term at Trebizon contains lots of hockey, music and bickering. And lots of clues as to why Tish is behaving strangely and what Nicola Hodges is up to.  I wonder if Anne Digby ever wrote adult detective stories, like Ruby Ferguson did? She'd have been good at them! I like Digby's characters but the stories are way too short. I like Balcombe Hall more than Trebizon, because although it's a very posh school, the characters seem more real and much more like some of the kids I was at school with. Wanting to leave at 16, taking no crap from the teachers, saying the food was &*#@ ...

But oh, what a difference it would have made to the inhabitants of Trebizon and Balcombe Hall if they'd been born a little later and enjoyed the benefits of modern technology.  At Trebizon, a quick Google on 'Hodges Road Haulage' would have saved Rebecca from having to ask awkward questions of the prefects (and it might have revealed impending disaster for Sue's father and saved a lot of bickering too). At Balcombe Hall, a mobile phone would have prevented Ariel from being kidnapped, or at least got her saved more quickly. And poor Mrs Vaux, deprived not only of the still in-the-future mobile but seemingly of even a landline in her flat at Balcombe Hall – she and her guests, locked in by Sylvia and co., only get out because the Admiral signals for help from the window!

On the first page of Captain at Springdale, Peggy Willoughby arrives at school and needs to go to the post office so she can buy stamps to send a postcard to tell her mother she's arrived safely. It struck me that 50 years on, with no mobiles and most likely no landline access except in emergencies at school, Rebecca and Jenny probably communicated with their parents in exactly the same way. What an incredible difference just 20 years has made in all our lives. No wonder fantasy is the preferred genre for authors in terms of writing for children and young adults – because the real world changes so fast that technology you write about in 2009 could well be completely outmoded by 2011 ...

Comments

( 4 comments — Leave a comment )
[info]witchy_rachel wrote:
May. 1st, 2009 02:02 pm (UTC)
I hadn't thought about the rise in fantasty writing in those terms, but now that I have, I think you're right!

I supose it also explains the interest in writing stories set in "days gone by".

You do make some awfully interesting posts you know!!
[info]lizarfau wrote:
May. 2nd, 2009 10:49 am (UTC)
Why, thank you! I am flattered!

Re. fantasy, there's also the fact that if you want an international book deal, fantasy is the genre to write in. Because your Other World with its own politics, myths and ways of doing things will be acceptable to people from pretty much every country. Whereas it can be a struggle in other genres because you're dealing with a particular place that may be very unfamiliar elsewhere.

But I think the technology and communications factor has to be a big part of it. As you say, an increasing number of books are set in the past. In the same vein, steampunk is popular too.

[info]dawn9163 wrote:
May. 2nd, 2009 12:07 am (UTC)
Last time I was doing a Drina re-read I was thinking similar things about technology and how everyone would have researched her mother and there would be no mystery at all.....

And yes that is a really interesting point about the scifi - although some of it is so dated now. I was reading something writted in the 50s that was quite up to date in one area of technology but still had them using slide rules for calculations which felt rather strange!
[info]lizarfau wrote:
May. 2nd, 2009 10:51 am (UTC)
Yes, I remember watching Space 1999 on DVD a few years ago and laughing at the ENORMOUS computers.

Actually, Harry Potter and his pals would have benefited from a bit of muggle technology on occasion. A mobile would have prevented that misunderstanding with Sirius in Order of the Phoenix, for example.
( 4 comments — Leave a comment )